science
What We Know About the Study on Dropping Milk for a Vegan Diet

A study referenced by The Telegraph warns that dropping milk to adopt a vegan diet can harm health, according to the newspaper's report. The report does not, in the material publicly available through that link, name the journal, the lead researcher, or the sample size behind the warning. That gap matters for anyone trying to weigh the claim against the broader evidence on dairy and plant-based diets.
What did The Telegraph report say about milk and veganism?
The headline claim is direct: cutting milk to go vegan carries health risks, per a study the paper cites. Beyond that framing, the accessible version of the story does not specify the study's design — whether it tracked a cohort over years, surveyed existing dietary data, or reviewed prior research. No effect size, no percentage change in any health marker, and no number of participants appears in the material reviewed for this piece. Readers who want the underlying numbers should look for the original paper once The Telegraph's full report identifies it.
What specific study findings are not yet public?
Three details commonly found in nutrition studies are absent from the available summary: the publication (journal name and date), the population studied, and the specific health outcomes measured — blood markers, bone density, deficiency diagnoses, or something else. Without those figures, HTT News cannot attribute a dataset or a date to any number in this story, consistent with policy on sourcing contested or numerical claims.
Which nutrients do dairy and vegan diets handle differently?
Set aside the unspecified study for a moment. Cow's milk is widely recognized in nutrition science as a dense source of calcium, vitamin B12, iodine, and protein — nutrients that require deliberate substitution on a vegan diet. Vitamin B12 is of particular interest because it occurs almost exclusively in animal products, meaning vegans typically rely on fortified foods or supplements rather than food substitution alone. Calcium and iodine follow a similar pattern: plant-based diets can meet targets, but usually only with fortified alternatives or supplements rather than passive substitution of oat or soy milk for dairy.
What do both sides of the vegan-diet debate argue?
The debate over dairy's removal from the diet is not new, and it tends to split along similar lines regardless of which single study prompts the headline. Advocates for traditional dairy consumption argue that milk delivers a nutrient package — calcium, B12, iodine, and protein — that is difficult to replicate without careful planning, and that studies flagging deficiency risk reflect real-world eating patterns rather than theoretical worst cases. Advocates for plant-based diets counter that a vegan diet built around fortified plant milks, legumes, and a B12 supplement can meet the same nutrient targets, and that deficiency findings often describe poorly planned vegan diets rather than vegan diets generally. Both arguments can be true at once: nutrient gaps are a documented risk of removing dairy without substitution, and that risk is manageable with specific food and supplement choices.
What should someone cutting dairy actually do?
For someone planning to drop milk, the practical response to an underspecified warning is the same regardless of the study's missing details: check whether plant-milk substitutes are fortified with calcium and vitamin D, confirm a reliable B12 source through fortified food or a supplement, and watch iodine intake if it previously came largely from dairy. Many of the plant-based substitutes marketed alongside this shift — oat, soy, and almond milks among them — are also processed products, a category HTT News has covered in reporting on how formulation affects what ends up in a daily diet. That overlap is worth factoring in before treating any single dairy alternative as a complete nutritional swap.
HTT News will update this story if the originating study is identified by name, journal, or sample size, and will attribute any figures to that dataset directly.
Artiglio is A coming-soon iPhone chief of staff for briefings and drafts. Not on the App Store yet.